Order from us for quality, customized work in due time of your choice.
>Please use at least 2 references in the reply and one must be from
Haig, S. (2007, July 25). My patients are not customers. Time. https://time.com/archive/6932081/my-patients-are-not-customers/
>Please reply to this discussion post:
Patients as Customers
The article by Haig (2007), “My Patients are Not Customers,” presents a critical perspective on viewing patients as traditional “customers” in the healthcare setting. Haig argues that healthcare involves complex interpersonal dynamics and life-impacting decisions that differ significantly from the transactional nature of conventional customer interactions. He emphasizes that patients are not merely consumers of a service but are often vulnerable individuals seeking care, trust, and expertise to address their health concerns. This perspective is also supported in the readings by Leger and Dunham-Taylor, particularly in Chapters 5 and 6, which highlight the ethical obligations and distinct roles of healthcare providers compared to those found in the customer service industry.
A healthcare “customer” refers to an individual or group engaging with healthcare services, whether for preventive, emergency, or chronic care. In contrast, the “market” for healthcare services encompasses a broader set of stakeholders, including patients, insurers, government entities, and even pharmaceutical companies. This distinction is crucial as healthcare services are driven by factors beyond simple supply and demand, which often dictate market behavior in other industries. For example, the necessity for specialized medical treatments does not wane with cost considerations alone; ethical considerations must also guide the healthcare market.
In terms of whether patients should be viewed as customers, I believe the perspective of patients as customers can be limited and potentially detrimental if taken too literally. While some elements of customer service—such as responsiveness, accessibility, and personalization—are beneficial to healthcare, the unique vulnerability of patients requires that healthcare providers focus on more than satisfaction metrics. A study by Reid et al. (2019) supports this view, suggesting that while patient-centered care aligns with certain customer service principles, the provider-patient relationship remains unique and should prioritize clinical outcomes over satisfaction alone. Thus, while the healthcare sector can adopt select customer-service practices to improve experience and access, it should refrain from fully assimilating patients into a “customer” model that may overlook the complexity and sanctity of healthcare interactions.
Marketing as a Recruitment Strategy
Marketing in healthcare is not only about promoting services but also plays a vital role in recruiting and retaining qualified healthcare professionals, thereby helping to build a robust, positive organizational image. Effective marketing can emphasize the unique culture, mission, and community impact of a healthcare organization, which are often deciding factors for potential employees. Leger and Dunham-Taylor, in Chapters 9 and 10, underscore the importance of a healthcare organization’s branding and public perception, especially in competitive markets where talent acquisition is challenging.
Healthcare organizations facing recruitment and retention issues can leverage marketing to cultivate a strong reputation, both within and outside the organization. For instance, creating campaigns that highlight employee testimonials, showcase success stories, and emphasize opportunities for professional development can attract candidates who align with the organization’s values and goals. Research by Lee et al. (2020) shows that healthcare organizations with a positive image and reputation for quality care and employee satisfaction are more successful in attracting top talent, even in high-demand fields. Additionally, healthcare organizations that invest in a solid public presence through community outreach, educational initiatives, and patient testimonials tend to foster a sense of community trust and support, which is critical to retaining talent and enhancing organizational stability.
Furthermore, marketing can also aid in creating a long-term image that reflects the organization’s dedication to both patient care and employee welfare. An organization’s involvement in health fairs, preventive care programs, and patient education initiatives, for instance, not only reinforces its commitment to the community but also attracts professionals motivated by a sense of purpose. Such strategies contribute to long-term brand loyalty, which benefits both recruitment and retention efforts.
In conclusion, viewing patients strictly as customers may neglect the unique care requirements that healthcare entails. Meanwhile, marketing in healthcare can be a powerful tool to support recruitment and retention, especially when it emphasizes the organization’s commitment to care, community, and professional growth. The evolving landscape of healthcare demands a balanced approach that acknowledges patients’ unique needs while also capitalizing on the organizational benefits of strategic, ethical marketing.
References
Haig, S. (2007). My patients are not customers. Time.com. Retrieved from https://time.com/Links to an external site.
Lee, M., Brown, A., & Smith, J. (2020). The role of marketing in healthcare recruitment and retention strategies. Journal of Healthcare Management, 65(2), 132-145.
Leger, J. M., & Dunham-Taylor, J. (2019). Healthcare Financial Management. New York: Pearson.
Reid, C., Mitchell, P., & Hansen, T. (2019). Patient-centered care in a customer-centered healthcare model: Implications for healthcare providers. Journal of Medical Ethics, 45(4), 390-397.
Order from us for quality, customized work in due time of your choice.